How to Create Genius Cheese Pairings

How to make a cheese plate with three cheeses, meats, and fruit

The first few times I had friends over for dinner, I was a total rookie. I’d plan out a fabulous menu consisting of several courses that I was sure would wow my guests, thinking it was completely fine that none of these courses could be prepared in advance (yeah…uh oh).

The result was the same every time. My friends would walk through the door to a kitchen cluttered with every single pot, pan, and dish dirtied on the counter or in the sink, and a harried and slightly grumpy hostess (yup, that would be me), trying to cook five things at once without burning or ruining anything.

These days I’m a bit more experienced and smarter about how to entertain guests, and part of my planning is to always (always, always!) have a cheese plate. Having a great cheese plate takes pressure off of me because I can set it up in advance and focus on the main course instead, and it also gives guests something to munch on when they arrive. Cheese and crackers don’t have to be boring as long as you’re making smart pairings and getting creative. So let me share some spring cheese pairing ideas with you!

As I see it, there are three major ways to put together a cheese plate.

Cheese Plate #1. Place a collection of complementary ingredients together on a platter, and let people play.

Cheese Pairing Ideas: strawberries, mint, aged cheddar, black pepper crackers, balsamic glaze

Each ingredient here has a different flavor sensation and texture, and any combination plays well together. The Cracker Barrel Vermont white is salty, savory, and smooth, the strawberries are sweet and acidic, the balsamic glaze has a sweet acidic bitterness, the mint is fresh and bright, and the crispy crackers have a bit of black pepper for spice. The strawberries, mint, and balsamic all have qualities that complement the rich, full flavor of the cheddar.

balsamic glaze, strawberry,aged reserve cheddar, mint, for cheese pairing hors d'ouerves

Cheese Plate #2. Assemble the cheese pairings as two-bite hors d’ouerves.

If you want people to enjoy a cheese pairing as an appetizer, you can assemble them in advance. Here I have caramelized leeks with some beautiful springtime asparagus with Cracker Barrel Aged Reserve shavings and a little sprinkling of sea salt on top of a butter cracker:

Leek asparagus cheddar shaving butter cracker cheese pairing bite

I prefer Cheddar shavings over Parmesan shavings here because the Aged Reserve shavings add a lovely creaminess but still have a complex, sharp flavor.

Cheese Plate #3. Make a classic cheese board with smartly selected cheeses, charcuterie, nuts, and dried fruit.

ideas for how to assemble a cheese plate or cheese board

For a classic cheese board, I think having three cheeses is perfect. Some guidelines:

  • Always have an authentic, good quality cheddar cheese as an anchor. Cheddar is the most widely produced and consumed cheese style in the world, and is always a favorite. I often pick Cracker Barrel’s Marbled Sharp because I love the mix of yellow and white cheddar (and this cheese solves my indecisive tendencies), though I love Cracker Barrel’s Aged Reserve as well.

  • Select three cheeses that are fairly different from each other. Mix and match different moisture contents, textures, fat contents, or type of milk. You might choose to have a sharp cheddar, a semi-soft blue cheese, and a hard cheese like parmesan or gruyere. Or maybe a cheddar, soft brie, and a gouda.

  • Add nuts (pecans, cayenne maple glazed walnuts, smoky almonds, etc), and have a sweet element on the cheese board too. Both dried fruit and fresh fruit work beautifully.

You can also add sweet, floral, tangy accents like quince paste (jammy, like a cross between apples and pears), clover honey (floral, sweet), balsamic glaze (tangy, slightly bitter), or high quality fruity or figgy jams.

quince paste, honey, and balsamic glaze pair well with cheese

The options are pretty much endless, but when thinking about what to pair, remember to consider the qualities of each ingredient you add, and aim for a balance of flavors and texture. Try to include an ingredient that hits each sensation of the taste buds: salty, sweet, sour, bitter, and umami.

What are some of your favorite cheese pairings?

Disclosure: I am proud to be a brand ambassador for Cracker Barrel Cheese. I grew up eating their cheeses and believe that they have very high quality yet reasonably priced and accessible cheeses. I have been compensated for my time but all opinions are my own.